Your aunt’s opinion about the fit of your Thanksgiving outfit or the number of Christmas cookies on your plate is not a medical credential.
There’s something about the holidays that makes people forget their manners. Could be the stress (or the third glass of eggnog) or maybe it’s the fact that everyone is suddenly within 18 inches of each other for six straight hours. Whatever it is, the holiday season has a way of turning perfectly ordinary family gatherings into an unsolicited commentary session about other people’s bodies.
“Have you lost weight?”
“Are you going back for seconds?”
“Oh honey, it took me awhile to get the baby weigh off too.”
“Are you sure you want to eat that?”
And my personal favorite: the person who announces they’ve decided to start a new diet in January while simultaneously explaining everything wrong with what everyone else is eating.
Oh, good. I was wondering when the nutrition seminar would begin.
Here’s a thought: Your body is not a holiday group project. Nobody needs to collaborate on it, critique it or offer suggestions for improvement.
And yet, somehow, the dinner table becomes the place where our bodies, our food choices and our appearance are suddenly considered open for public discussion.
Let’s stop doing that.
Your body is not a conversation starter
We have somehow normalized commenting on people’s bodies as if it’s a form of affection. We congratulate people for losing weight. We question them when they’ve gained it. We praise them for looking smaller, ask what they’re doing differently, and sometimes even demand to know their secrets. We mean well, right? Maybe. But good intentions don’t automatically make a comment appropriate.
The American Psychological Association’s guidance on inclusive language specifically recommends avoiding unsolicited commentary about someone’s weight or changes in their appearance. Even compliments about weight loss can carry unintended consequences.
Think about it. What if the weight loss was the result of illness, grief, stress or a difficult season of life? What if someone is struggling with their relationship with food? What if they simply don’t want their body to be the subject of conversation?
And even if someone has worked hard toward a personal health goal, they still don’t owe anyone an explanation. You can be happy for someone without making their body the headline. A simple “It’s so good to see you!” works beautifully. Try it sometime.
Food is not a moral achievement
Somewhere along the way, we decided food needed a moral classification system: Salad is good. Cake is bad. Eating clean is virtuous. Having another helping means you’ve lost control. And heaven forbid someone mention that they’ve been “good” all week before eating a piece of pie.
Listen, food is food. It provides nourishment, brings people together, carries cultural meaning and, occasionally, makes an absolutely spectacular appearance in the form of your grandmother’s homemade dressing. We can care about our health without turning every meal into a character assessment.
There is also a real difference between making intentional choices about your health and allowing those choices to become a source of shame or obsession.
Research published in Nature Medicine found that weight stigma can have significant psychological and physical consequences. The idea that shaming someone about their weight will motivate healthier behavior simply isn’t supported by the evidence.
In fact, the National Eating Disorders Association identifies weight stigma as a contributor to body dissatisfaction and unhealthy eating behaviors.
So perhaps we can retire the commentary about who is eating what, who is skipping dessert and who needs to get back on track after the holidays. You don’t know someone’s health history, relationship with food, medical circumstances or personal goals. And you don’t need to.
You can have health goals AND boundaries
Now, let’s be clear about something.
This isn’t about abandoning your health goals, pretending body image is always easy, or insisting that every choice we make is automatically healthy. You can want to get stronger, work toward a healthier lifestyle, have personal goals about nutrition, movement, and how you feel in your body. You can also enjoy Thanksgiving dinner without calculating how many miles you’ll need to walk afterward. Both things can be true.
The problem starts when we allow other people’s expectations to become the measuring stick for our own progress.
Maybe you’ve lost weight. Maybe you’ve gained weight. Maybe you’re maintaining. Maybe your body has changed because you’re getting older, recovering from something, navigating motherhood or simply living your life. Your worth did not increase or decrease with your clothing size. And your progress doesn’t need to be validated by the people sitting around your holiday table.
One of the most important things we can learn is that boundaries don’t require a dramatic announcement. Sometimes they’re just a simple sentence delivered with a smile.
Try these:
- “I’m happy with what I’m eating, thanks!”
- “I’d rather not make my body a topic of conversation.”
- “I’m focusing on enjoying the day, not discussing diets.”
- “My health is something I’m handling with my healthcare provider.”
- “Let’s talk about something more interesting. How’s work?”
And if someone continues? You’re allowed to change the subject, walk away, or decline to participate. You do not have to defend a boundary to make it legitimate.
Give yourself permission to enjoy the holiday
I think we spend far too much time worrying about how we’re being perceived and not nearly enough time actually enjoying the lives we’re living.
We worry about how we look in photographs. We compare our bodies to the person standing next to us. We wonder whether our clothes fit differently than last year. We agonize over what we ate, what we shouldn’t have eaten, and what we’ll need to do about it tomorrow. Meanwhile, the people we love are gathered around the table.
The kids are getting older. The conversations are changing. The people we wish could be there aren’t always there. And the moments we think we’ll have forever are passing right in front of us. I don’t want you to miss the good stuff because you’re busy worrying about whether your stomach looks flat in a family photo.I don’t want you to spend an entire afternoon feeling guilty about enjoying your favorite food. And I certainly don’t want you to believe that your body has to meet someone else’s expectations before you deserve to feel confident, beautiful, or comfortable in your own skin.
Confidence isn’t always walking into a room feeling like the best-looking person there. Sometimes confidence is sitting at the table, eating the pie, wearing the outfit, and refusing to let somebody else’s opinion ruin a perfectly good afternoon.That’s a kind of freedom worth working toward.
So this holiday season, let’s make a little agreement.
We’ll stop commenting on other people’s plates. We’ll stop treating weight loss like a competitive sport. We’ll stop handing out unsolicited advice disguised as concern.
And we’ll remember that the people sitting across from us are so much more than their appearance.
Including ourselves.
Your body doesn’t need a committee, a public relations strategy or a family approval rating. It deserves respect. Period.
Now go enjoy your holiday. And if your aunt has something to say about your second helping of pie, remind her that her opinion wasn’t on the menu.
Want to Go Deeper?
If this holiday season has you thinking about confidence, boundaries and the expectations we place on ourselves, let’s keep that conversation going.
Michelle speaks to audiences about personal growth, authentic confidence, resilience and navigating the expectations of others.
Interested in bringing Michelle to your next event, conference or organization? Visit bishoplife.com to learn more.
Related Blog Posts
Mental Wellness, Nutrition, Physical Health
Mental Wellness, Nutrition, Physical Health, Spiritual Wellness
Mental Wellness, Nutrition, Physical Health
